Skip to main content
The Beria Principle

Home Secretary, Charles Clarke was arguing this morning, that mobile telephone records be kept for three years as a means of assisting police in future investigations which may or my not include terrorist offences.

In the wake of last week’s events in London, it seems inevitable that government, confronted by a total failure of the intelligence gathering apparatus of the state, will explore every possible opportunity for information and evidence gathering in the future and this may include the resurrection of arguments that once surrounded the original drafting of the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act (RIPA) that you may recall gave “snooping rights” - at least in principle - to any “official”, down to the rank of Traffic Warden, as presenter Jeremy Paxman pointed out to a Home Office Minister on a BBC Newsnight programme in 2001.

It was Stalin’s Chief of Police, Lavrenty Beria, who first made the collection of detailed information on citizens into a science but even he might not have been able to imagine the ambition of some of the legislative proposals offered to Parliament by the Home Office in recent years and which fortunately for us, have been diluted or thrown-out by the House of Lords. In retrospect, it’s unlikely that such ideas might have been able to deter last week’s atrocity and while we need to be able offer the police and intelligence services the tools they need to prevent a repeat of the London bombings, technology, used as a blunt instrument of policy, is not the answer.

Unfortunately, I’ve had direct experience of terrorism in the days before the appearance mobile phones and personal computers and today’s terrorists or potential terrorists know only too well, that to use technology is to invite the risk of attention, which may partly explain why the police and intelligence services had no idea that we have a cadre of suicide bombers living among us, a group that is loyal to an ideology of conflict and not an organisation, Al Qaeda which now only exists as a brand of terrorism, a lens which collects and focuses the hatred of a disaffected minority.

Fighting terrorism with technology can only give you an “ah ha” moment if the technology is able to identify a pattern of behaviour. Deprive government of the ability to deploy tanks, aircraft and computers against the threat and we’re back once more to the classic theory of Guerrilla warfare, “The War of the Flea”, articulated by Mao Tse Tung, Che Guevara and others. History’s lesson shows that when a government, confronted by the threat of direct action by a minority, dramatically increases its intelligence gathering powers and restricts civil liberties, it simply makes matters worse and not better.

The uneasy truth of London last Thursday is that all the satellites, scanners, ID cards and laws in the world won’t protect the citizens United States and Europe from the determined activities of a group prepared to deploy home-grown, teenage suicide bombers against the society in which they live. Encouraged by the propaganda found on a thousand internet sites and protected by the civil liberties that define our modern society, terrorists have presented us with the stark message that technology is their tool and not our weapon in a conflict of ideologies which may run for decades.


Popular posts from this blog

Mainframe to Mobile

Not one of us has a clue what the world will look like in five years’ time, yet we are all preparing for that future – As  computing power has become embedded in everything from our cars and our telephones to our financial markets, technological complexity has eclipsed our ability to comprehend it’s bigger picture impact on the shape of tomorrow.

Our intuition has been formed by a set of experiences and ideas about how things worked during a time when changes were incremental and somewhat predictable. In March 1953. there were only 53 kilobytes of high-speed RAM on the entire planet.

Today, more than 80 per cent of the value of FTSE 500* firms is ‘now dark matter’: the intangible secret recipe of success; the physical stuff companies own and their wages bill accounts for less than 20 per cent: a reversal of the pattern that once prevailed in the 1970s. Very soon, Everything at scale in this world will be managed by algorithms and data and there’s a need for effective platforms for ma…
A Christmas Tale

It’s pitch blackness in places along the sea wall this evening and I'm momentarily startled by a small dog with orange flashing yuletide antlers along the way. I’m the only person crazy enough to be running and I know the route well enough to negotiate it in the dark, part of my Christmas exercise regime and a good way of relieving stress.

Why stress you might ask. After all, it is Christmas Day.

True but I’ve just spent over two hours assembling the giant Playmobil ‘Pony Farm’ set when most other fathers should be asleep in front of the television.

I was warned that the Playmobil ‘Pirate Ship’ had driven some fathers to drink or suicide and now I understand why. If your eyesight isn’t perfect or if you’ve had a few drinks with your Christmas lunch then it’s a challenge best left until Boxing day but not an option if you happen to have a nine year old daughter who wants it ready to take horses by tea time.

Perhaps I should stick to technology but then, the instruc…

An Ockham of Gatwick

The 13th century theologian and philosopher, William of Ockham, who once lived in his small Surrey village, not so very far from what is today, the wide concrete expanse of Gatwick airport is a frequently referenced source of intellectual reason. His contribution to modern culture was Ockham’s Razor, which cautions us when problem solving, that “The explanation requiring the fewest assumptions is most likely to be correct;” sound advice which constantly proves to be true.

A week further-on since Britain’s second busiest airport was bought to a complete standstill by two or perhaps two hundred different drone sightings, it is perhaps time to revisit William of Ockham’s maxim, rather than be led astray by an increasingly bizarre narrative, one which has led Surrey police up several blind alleys with little or nothing in the way of measurable results.

 Exploring the possibilities with a little help in reasoning from our medieval friar, we appear to have a choice of two different account…